The Preamble to the CONSTITUTION OF THE STATE OF WISCONSIN states;
“We, the people of Wisconsin, grateful to Almighty God…”
Whoa, whoa, whoa! Has anyone told those folks who are suing the Elmbrook school district that God is mentioned in our State Constitution? If they find out, can a lawsuit be far behind?
I have a unique perspective on this issue. In 2001, our oldest son graduated from Brookfield East High School. The ceremony was held in the gym. We knew that across town Brookfield Central was using Elmbrook Church for their ceremony but many of us felt that our kids should graduate in the school they attended. Until that day it seemed like a good idea. Picture this; a gym built in 1961, no air conditioning and its hotter than the flames of hell (which may or may not exist depending on your personal beliefs but I am using this as a metaphor so please don’t sue me). The gym floor is lined with chairs reserved for the graduating class. You have no idea what it’s like to watch scores of 70, 80, and 90 year olds try to navigate their way up the wooden bleachers to try and find seats. It’s a miracle no Grandmas or Grandpas were lost that day. Of course, not all Grandparents could be there. Because of the limited space many family members could not attend. Did I mention the awful sound system preventing the majority of the crowd from hearing anything? How about the horrible sight lines making photos and videos virtually impossible? How about folks with disabilities? Good luck.
By the time our other son and our daughter graduated from Brookfield East the ceremony had moved to Elmbrook Church. I am not a member of that church but I did thank God those days for that building (under my breath so as not to offend others).
Our family wasn’t there to attend a worship service. We were there to salute our children for their accomplishments. I honestly would have been fine in a Mosque, Synagogue, or Buddhist Center. If it was climate controlled, handicap accessible, had ample space, and was easy for elderly relatives, I’m all in. Plus, I always thought a Church was comprised of people sharing their faith and where they choose to worship is of little consequence (once again, just my own belief which may or may not be in line with yours so don’t be offended).
By the way, according to a Marquette Law blogger;
“There is, incidentally, Wisconsin precedent on the matter. In State ex rel. Conway v. Joint School Board No. 6, a 1916 decision, the Wisconsin Supreme Court held that holding graduation ceremonies in a church does not violate Wisconsin’s version of the religion clauses, Art. I, sec. 18 (which is worded differently than the federal provisions). Should this issue go to court, the United States Supreme Court’s interpretation of the United States Constitution will take precedence.”
I know the group that is suing has pressured New Berlin, Mukwonago and WCTC into moving their ceremonies out of Elmbrook Church but I hope the Brookfield schools don’t cave. Next year they would be moving back to their newly refurbished gymnasiums anyway so unless the school is covertly recruiting members for the Church (and they’re not) I say leave ‘em alone. Don’t we have bigger fish to fry?
(the fish fry usually perceived as a Lenten celebration but if you’re not Catholic, I apologize; please don’t sue me).
I know Thomas Jefferson got this whole thing going when he mentioned the separation of church and state. But I guarantee you that if his mother-in-law had to climb wooden bleachers and sit in a one hundred degree gymnasium, well, he would have given all schools involved a hall pass. And he would’ve been at the church early. You know, to reserve a good pew.